It’s the worst thing you can see when you go out into your garden. Weeds. Don’t you wish there’s an easy answer? Who wants to go down on hands and knees to pry them from the ground, right? Today, we’re going to help solve your problem.
Below you’ll find a few reviews on weed killing products we recently researched and tried out. We’re going to share our findings so you can get the best solution for your garden. There’s no reason to struggle any longer. You can banish weeds from your premises.
- 1 Top-Rated Weed Killers
- 2 Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer (TOP Choice)
- 3 Roundup Weed and Grass Killer (Best Value)
- 4 Scotts Fertilizer and Weed Killer
- 5 Ortho GroundClear Vegetation Killer
- 6 Southern Ag 2,4-D Amine Broadleaf Weed Control
- 7 RM43 43-Percent Glyphosate Plus Weed Preventer
- 8 Spectracide Weed Stop For Lawns
- 9 Bayer Advanced Weed and Crabgrass Killer
- 10 Southern Ag Crossbow Specialty Herbicide
- 11 PBI/Gordon Speed Zone Lawn Weed Killer
- 12 Weed Killers Buying Guide
Top-Rated Weed Killers
Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer (TOP Choice)
What is one of the biggest challenges when working with chemicals in your garden? Rain of course. You don’t want all the important particles to wash away before they even started working.
If you’re living in a high rainfall area, this concentrate should be on your shopping list. It’s rainproof within two hours, so you have minimal risk of losing out on its effects. The weeds will disappear thanks to the high concentrate—41%-of glyphosate.
But take note, this substance kills everything. Don’t put it on your grass if you still want it. However, it’s ideal for clearing weeds from walkways and can be added in between vegetables to kill weeds, as long as it’s not on the plants themselves.
But here’s what’s amazing about it and one of the reasons why it’s our top choice. It will kill everything today, but 24hours into the future, you can start planting new flora again.
- Fast results: You can see plants dying within two days of application.
- Economical: A one-gallon bottle will help you treat up to 25 000ft².
- Powerful: It kills the plant to the root.
- Reasonably priced: It’s no more expensive than similar products on the market.
- No distinction: Grass will die as well.
- Delayed effect: Depending on the strength of the mixture, the weeds may take a few days to die completely.
- Can’t store: Days after mixing with water the product may become sticky which can block sprayers.
Roundup Weed and Grass Killer (Best Value)
Here’s a favorite of many gardeners and for us, it was one of best weed killers for lawns. What are your most important requirements of a weed killer? Roundup is well known because this super concentrate performs well in many areas:
- It’s rainproof within half an hour
- Weeds wilt quickly
- You get 85 gallons from a one-gallon canister
This product works by entering the plant through the leaves. This will channel the glyphosate to the roots. The entire plant will be affected and die as a result. You’ll see them completely dead at the end of two weeks.
With 50.2% of the substance being glyphosate and isopropylamine salt, you can be sure it’s one of the strongest weed killers mentioned in these reviews. Doing this review, we saw how important it is to keep to the dilution directions on labels. The manufacturers know exactly how much is necessary to have the desired effect.
- Resilient: Rain won’t wash the particles away, so they can go on working.
- Support: The brand provides supporting gear such as sprayers and the product comes in a variety of sizes.
- Fast acting: The first effects will be seen within 12 hours.
- Dangerous: You can’t use this in the vicinity of edible plants such as your vegetables.
- Faulty directions: Many users find better results when mixing double the amount of Roundup.
- Not a permanent solution: After about a month you’ll need to reapply.
Scotts Fertilizer and Weed Killer
This is an upgraded product, so you can be sure you’ll be impressed by some of the enhancements. Specifically, this is a guaranteed product to fight Dandelions and Clover. Are they your biggest challenges too?
Here’s what you’ll love about Scotts. You can do two things with one product:
- Get rid of weeds from their roots upwards.
- Fertilize and feed your grass so it grows lusher.
Yes, one product can do it all so you save money and time.
- Diverse: It’s beneficial to many different types of grass.
- Effective: It targets even the weeds not visible from the surface.
- Beneficial to grass: Grass areas flourish after applying this.
- Different products: You can pick the size bag that matches your yard so you don’t waste money or product.
- Long timelines: It can take up to 24 hours for the particles to settle and start affecting plants
- Efficacy varies: Not all weeds are affected as well as dandelions and clover, so you may need additional products.
- Not strong enough: Some lawns may need a second application to get rid of all weeds.
Ortho GroundClear Vegetation Killer
How would you like not worrying about weed growth for 365 days? That’s what this product promises and we saw its impressive results. This professional product also has the active ingredient of glyphosate, along with Imazapyr, Isopropylamine salt and many other particles that make it so powerful & effective.
If you have a driveway, gravel area or gate that you need to rid of plants and weeds, this will work. And thanks to its unique formula they won’t come back for a long time. The brand also caters to everyone, as you can pick your preferred type between a concentrate or ready-to-use substance.
And why struggle with an application if you can use the comfort and feature that comes with some of their liquids? This is an effective and effortless solution, even for commercial grade application.
- Application method: Simply use the provided wand to keep the substance off your face and clothing.
- Fast: You’ll see results within hours.
- Incorrect directions: A stronger solution is necessary to be effective on stronger plants.
- Inaccurate timeline prediction: It works longer than other products, but not always for a year.
Southern Ag 2,4-D Amine Broadleaf Weed Control
If broadleaf weeds – such as dandelion and chickweed – are your biggest challenges, this could be your answer. You have a 46.3% concentrate of Dimethylamine salt that will fight on your behalf.
Note that this makes it a very customized product, so don’t pick this for other types of weeds. But if you need a solution for one of these areas, this will usually do the trick:
- Golf course greens
And yes, you can try it on your home’s lawn too. One important factor in application is being accurate. You won’t eradicate all your problems if you don’t ensure each problematic plant is sprayed thoroughly.
- Fast: You should see the result within 24 hours.
- Strong: It’s a potent mixture, so you don’t have to use too much to have an effect on a plant.
- Long lasting: This most effective weed control will keep broadleaf at bay for quite a while.
- User-friendly: Mixing instructions and usage are fairly easy to understand.
- Selective: You won’t kill all weeds with this one product.
- Kills grass: You can’t apply this to your grass, as it may kill it along with the weeds.
RM43 43-Percent Glyphosate Plus Weed Preventer
Trust the big red container if you want to try keeping weeds at bay for a year. This product also promises long-term effects and it’s made possible through the active ingredients:
- Isopropylamine salt
With one gallon you can treat over 17 000ft². This is noticeably less than some other items on this list, and it’s more expensive. But if the long-term effects are valuable to you, it may still be something to consider. As long as you keep this away from the roots of the plants you still want to keep, you can spray it almost anywhere you want to kill weeds.
It’s known to control:
Note that it may take a while to soak into the ground. It will happen faster if you wet the ground or if there’s soft rain, but make sure it doesn’t wash into areas you don’t want it to work.
- Strongest ingredients: Works effectively on certain plants and weeds.
- Long lasting: If applied correctly weeds take months before returning.
- Prevention plan: If you want to prevent weeds ever invading your perfect garden, this substance can work to keep them at bay.
- Dangerous: Don’t use near crops or plants you want to eat in future.
- Efficacy varies: It won’t kill the tougher weeds as easily as grass.
- Slow working: You won’t see effects as fast as some other products on this list.
- Packaging: Leaking often occurs as a container is not of high quality.
Spectracide Weed Stop For Lawns
Here’s another customized product and this time the target is Crabgrass. Have a look at the container and you can see what you can look forward to. This product promises to:
- Start killing within 8 hours thanks to the strongest ingredients used.
- Destroy the plant from within, in a matter of four days.
Once again the company ensures you can tailor your gardening to your preferences:
- Use the concentrate if you want to dilute it yourself.
- Use ready-to-spray products with the handy nozzle for an effortless gardening session.
Although it’s designed to work on Crabgrass, it’s proven to kill over 250 other types of weeds too, even the tough ones. No wonder it’s often mentioned in the top of the range reviews.
- Economical: With only a 32oz bottle you can treat up to 5 000ft² of your garden.
- Affordable: It’s one of the cheapest brands on the market.
- Fast acting: See the weeds die before your eyes.
- User-friendly: The bottles with nozzles make application easy.
- The effect varies: Some users find it minimizes but doesn’t eradicate weeds.
- Kills grass: If a mix is too strong your grass may suffer too.
- Multiple applications necessary: You may not see the desired effect after one go, so be prepared to apply again within a few days.
Bayer Advanced Weed and Crabgrass Killer
Have peace of mind that your grass won’t die, while you fight off many other unwanted plants. This is the Bayer Advanced promise. The product is designed to kill over 200 types of weeds, even tough ones by killing them from the roots outward. The product is so specific that even grass-like weeds can be destroyed such as Crabgrass.
Note that this is not ideal for use on certain grass types including:
- Bahia grass
- St Augustines
You may harm more than help them.
You will love the practical features of Bayer Advanced since it won’t prevent you from doing other gardening activities. You can mow your lawn as soon as two days after applying this.
Here’s a tip: In dry seasons you can water the lawn a few days before applying this. This ensures it’s more effective.
- Fast acting: The product clings to the plants immediately so it’s rainproof within 60 minutes.
- Grass friendly: You can kill weeds in between grass.
- Practical: Another gardening – such as mowing – can continue soon after application.
- Packaging: Container with nozzle also available.
- Economical: With only 40oz you can treat up to 5 000ft².
- Low efficacy: You may need more than one application before seeing an effect.
- Crabgrass friendly: It may hinder Crabgrass growing fast, but rarely kills it off completely.
- A danger to flowers: The focus is on grass weeds, not those you find between flowers, so it may harm flowering plants.
Southern Ag Crossbow Specialty Herbicide
Limit the physical actions necessary to destroy unwanted brush or bushes. You can first kill them off with herbicides and then hack away the dying parts. And that’s what Southern Ag Crossbow is excellent for.
It’s strong enough to kill off most brush and even trees. The effect is thanks to the active particles from:
- 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid
- Butoxyethyl ester
- Triclopyr BEE
Note that ester products carry some danger, so don’t spray this without taking into consideration where the particles can be carried by the wind. If it lands in your home, it may affect people’s health. If it drifts onto the grass and the weather is very dry, it may burn the shoots.
- Practical: You can use this for spot treatment.
- Specific: Safe to use near or on the grass in cool conditions.
- Versatile: Kills many types of weeds.
- Multiple applications necessary: This isn’t the most potent product on this list.
- Costly: More expensive than some of its counterparts.
- Not user-friendly: Directions for dilution are on the back of the label and the brand doesn’t make a ready-to-use liquid.
- Difficult to control: It doesn’t fix plants immediately, so may drift elsewhere in dry windy conditions.
PBI/Gordon Speed Zone Lawn Weed Killer
Here is another herbicide containing ester products, so know that you have to use it with caution.
The ingredients include:
- Mecoprop-p acid
- Dicamba acid
- 2.4D 2-Ethylhexyl ester
Because it works on a variety of weeds, it’s a favorite of many avid gardeners.
- Economical: Treat up to 18 000ft² with only 20oz.
- Versatile: You can combat different kinds of weeds with one product.
- Grass friendly: Your grass won’t die but the weeds in between it will.
- Fast action: You’ll see results in hours.
- Strong: Known to kill tough weeds that other products don’t.
- Timeline: Weeds are only completely dead after two weeks.
- Expensive: It’s pricier than other similar products (though it does cover a large area).
- Varied results: On some weeds, you may need multiple applications to kill them off completely.
Weed Killers Buying Guide
So how do you know which one to pick?
No, there is no one perfect weed killer, because each garden is different. If you want the perfect solution, you must first analyze your problem. Then we’ll find the ideal product that matches your specifications. So before you go to the store to buy a herbicide, here are a few things to keep in mind.
What is your goal? Weeds may be a general term for you, but if you want to find the perfect killer, you need to know what you’re up against.
Certain herbicides are designed to kill off a specific type of plant, such as:
- Broadleaved weeds
Write down what your challenge is and search for appropriate products. Will the herbicide you consider also kill off your grass? If you don’t want this to happen, look for grass-friendly products. Alternatively, you’ll only be able to use the product on gravel or stone areas.
Don’t think the most expensive item will be the best. The product that will rid you of a specific weed may be the cheapest one on the market.
But if you find expensive top-rated weed and grass killers, it’s worth investing in it. Cheaper versions may be less effective. This may require multiple applications or they may never work. This means you’ll spend as much as you do on the expensive products, without getting the effect you want.
And don’t forget you can cost yourself a lot of money if you buy cheap products that state they will help your grass, but end up killing it. Then you’ll spend your money on building your garden from scratch.
Can you see why it’s important to purchase the right item and not simply follow the advice your neighbors broadcast? Each situation is unique.
How quickly do you need to see effects? This isn’t the most important feature, as usual, it’s simply necessary that the weeds eventually disappear. But in some circumstances, this may be a deciding factor. Do you need your garden to be ready for an upcoming event? Luckily the fastest products kill weeds within days.
How long must you wait before you know the particles are attached to the plants and won’t wash away? It’s called rainproof and this is important if you want to plan to water your garden. And if it rains soon after you applied the product, you may need to add another application, as the chemicals may have washed away.
The other important timeline is how long it will keep weeds at bay. It doesn’t make sense using a substance and seeing weeds return within weeks. Few products can promise to keep your weeds away forever, as the substance eventually disappears from the soil. However, there are herbicides that work for months on end. If you need to keep maintenance or labor costs low, this can be one of your important requirements.
Marketing can be misleading. Is it really wise to purchase the less expensive product if you need to keep to a budget? Not if the concentrate won’t cover a large part of your garden.
I advise you to go to the store with a calculator and compare the different products’ economical values. Usually the packaging mentions:
- How concentrated the mixture must be
- How big an area the concentrate will effectively treat
Now in a comparison, find the most economical one for your large areas. If the cheap product can only treat a very small area, your final expense will be extremely high.
Of course, good herbicides contain dangerous ingredients. After all, something is supposed to kill the weeds.
But what organisms will find the particles dangerous?
- Is it safe to use around your home where kids play?
- Can you use it on edible plants such as your fruit trees?
Use these guidelines to decide whether you want to risk using it, or rather try a less dangerous option.
Gardening can be fun, but not everyone loves mixing liquids. If this is you, why not consider popular products that make it easier? It will save you time and effort if you pick a product that is already mixed & has a nozzle that sprays.
Luckily for you – as can be seen in this review – good herbicide manufacturers cater for everyone in the market, even you.